Fakey McFake
Except when I received it, it was quite plainly not a red aventurine in a sterling setting. It was a hunk of composite resin in a junk metal setting. It didn't look like a stone, feel like a stone, or have the weight of a stone. If you have any interest WHATSOEVER in minerals or gemstones, you are not going to be fooled by this.
And that's what pissed me off. "Magic," sure, whatever. I did not expect it to shoot sparks or allow me to speak Parseltongue. But to send a fake junk pendant? What the hell? It's not even like aventurine is an expensive or rare stone. To fake that, you have to be one of two things: a total idiot or a moral bankrupt.
But I figured I'd give her the benefit of the doubt. So I emailed her. She was instantly hostile in her reply, claiming OF COURSE it was an aventurine and I had damaged it (true) so it wasn't returnable and that was that. (I did, in fact, scratch the back discreetly with a metal file just to prove to myself there was no way it was an aventurine. I naively offered this up as evidence to her that this was not the correct item.)
She didn't even try to pretend it was a mistake or play dumb or act as though maybe she'd gotten a bad pendant from her supplier, so I knew, at that point, what I was dealing with.
I took the pendant to a jeweler/gemologist down the street from me, who was totally dumbfounded that anyone would try to pass this thing off as a stone.
"At the very least, if you wanted to pretend it was something, coral would have been a better choice. I mean, it's orange and opaque."
She regretfully told me that if I wanted her to write this up officially, she'd have to charge me. I decided to wait on that, since I only paid $20 for this bubblegum machine crap, and a professional appraisal would cost more than that. And I opened a PayPal dispute.
And I explained the whole thing carefully, and offered to send an appraisal if it was considered necessary, and this morning, they closed the case and ruled in her favor. Um? I instantly sent a complaint, which (of course) has not been replied to yet.
This is a tidy little scam she has running. Sell one hundred $0.10 pendants a month at $20.00 a pop, then you're spending $10 (plus listing fees and postage) and making $2000. And yet, the things she are selling are cheap enough to have this whole scam fly right under the radar. Not many people are going to recognize a fake stone or care, or be willing to pay $50 to prove the $20 stone is fake. You know what I mean?
I should have paid attention to the small percentage of negative feedback. When I went back to actually READ it all, they said essentially the same thing: FAKE. But apparently, 98% of buyers don't care about that, as long as the piece of junk might eventually make fairies show up in your bedroom closet or summon a genie to do your bidding.
I guess at this point, I have to just let it go, and thank the experience for getting me interested in making my own jewelry. But man, the unrepentant scamming just rankles me. A magic scam -- okay, caveat emptor. Selling gemstones and sending plastic? Kind of illegal. But apparently no one at PayPal or eBay cares about such trifles, so ... I'm out $20. Boo hiss.
Labels: caveat emptor, ebay, scams



